| College | Men | Women |
|---|---|---|
| Bethany College | 4:56 | 6:15 |
| Bethel | 4:36 | - |
| Evangel | 4:43 | 5:24 |
| Friends University | 4:41 | 5:31 |
| Kansas Wesleyan | 4:42 | 5:38 |
| McPherson | 4:36 | 5:46 |
| Oklahoma Wesleyan | 4:45 | - |
| Ottawa | 4:37 | 6:01 |
| Southwestern | 4:40 | 5:31 |
| St. Mary | 4:33 | 5:27 |
| Sterling College | 4:47 | 5:43 |
| Tabor | 4:38 | 5:36 |
| York | 4:59 | 5:43 |
| College | Men | Women |
|---|---|---|
| Bethany College | 5:00 | 6:30 |
| Bethel | 4:44 | - |
| Evangel | 4:52 | 5:49 |
| Friends University | 4:53 | 5:45 |
| Kansas Wesleyan | 4:52 | 5:55 |
| McPherson | 4:52 | 6:03 |
| Oklahoma Wesleyan | 4:53 | - |
| Ottawa | 4:53 | 6:14 |
| Southwestern | 4:49 | 5:37 |
| St. Mary | 4:49 | 5:41 |
| Sterling College | 4:53 | 5:43 |
| Tabor | 4:47 | 5:53 |
| York | 5:02 | 6:09 |
* estimated by Runcruit using performance data of current and recent teams