| College | Men | Women |
|---|---|---|
| Bethel | 4:45 | 5:48 |
| Goshen | 4:32 | 5:37 |
| Grace | 4:40 | 5:31 |
| Huntington | 4:34 | 5:10 |
| Indiana Wesleyan | 4:24 | 5:15 |
| Marian | 4:21 | 5:21 |
| Mount Vernon Nazarene | 4:33 | 5:45 |
| Spring Arbor | 4:31 | 5:42 |
| St Francis | 4:40 | 5:20 |
| Taylor | 4:29 | 5:12 |
| College | Men | Women |
|---|---|---|
| Bethel | 4:54 | 5:55 |
| Goshen | 4:47 | 5:45 |
| Grace | 4:50 | 5:47 |
| Huntington | 4:46 | 5:29 |
| Indiana Wesleyan | 4:38 | 5:36 |
| Marian | 4:37 | 5:44 |
| Mount Vernon Nazarene | 4:44 | 5:56 |
| Spring Arbor | 4:37 | 5:57 |
| St Francis | 4:47 | 5:37 |
| Taylor | 4:43 | 5:30 |
* estimated by Runcruit using performance data of current and recent teams